Fractional CFO comparisons.

Fractional CFO vs full-time CFO, finance director, accountant and finance manager: what each does, when each fits, and which to hire first.

By William Smithwhite, Fractional CFO (ex-Credit Suisse, MFin IE Business School). Last updated 10 November 2026.

Which finance hire do you need?

It depends on what is holding the business back. If the books and tax returns are the problem, you need an accountant. If nobody has time for invoices, payments and month-end, you need a finance manager. If you have the numbers but can't see cash ahead, or the board and investors want more than you can produce, you need senior finance leadership, and for most startups and SMEs that starts part-time.

The main finance hires, what each does and when it fits
What they doWhen it fits
AccountantBookkeeping, year-end accounts, tax returns and compliance.From day one. Every business needs accurate, filed numbers.
Finance managerRuns day-to-day finance: invoices, payments, reconciliations and month-end.When the volume of day-to-day finance work is too much for the founder or the accountant.
Fractional CFOAdds the annual budget, scenarios, board pack and meetings, investor reporting and strategic support.When decisions, the board or a raise need senior finance judgement, for businesses up to around £40m.
Full-time CFOA permanent senior hire who owns the whole finance function and team.Above that size, or with a complex group or a sustained raise.

Many businesses use more than one: an accountant for compliance, a finance manager or an outsourced FD for the operational work, and a CFO for direction. Oro covers the reporting and the direction through Management Accounts and Fractional CFO, done personally by William. If you are not sure which stage you are at, read when do you need a fractional CFO? or see the work in our case studies.

The comparisons

Each comparison sets out what the two options do, where they overlap and when each is the right choice. None of them assume a fractional CFO is always the answer.

Frequently asked questions

Can a fractional CFO work alongside our accountant?
Yes, and that is the usual set-up. Your accountant keeps the year-end accounts, tax returns and compliance. The fractional CFO uses the same numbers to produce monthly management accounts, a cash forecast and board reporting, so the two roles add to each other rather than overlap.
When should we hire a full-time CFO?
When finance needs someone senior every day, not a few days a month. Most businesses up to around £40m are well served by a fractional CFO; above that, or with a complex group or a sustained raise, a full-time hire starts to make sense. Until then, watch for finance becoming the bottleneck, such as board and investor reporting eating the founder's time.
What's the difference between a CFO and an FD?
An FD (finance director) runs the finance function: month-end, controls, compliance and the team. A CFO owns the strategic decisions: margin, cash, capital, raises and exits. In a smaller business one person often covers both, and a fractional CFO can do the strategic part a few days a month.