How to choose a CFO advisor for a UK consumer brand

Eight criteria for choosing a CFO advisor for a UK consumer brand, from channel and wholesale margins to fixed fees and who does the work, plus intro call questions.

By William Smithwhite, Fractional CFO (ex-Credit Suisse, MFin IE Business School). Last updated 30 October 2026.

What should a consumer brand look for in a CFO advisor?

Look for someone who has worked on the numbers of a consumer brand before and can show you the output. A consumer brand makes and loses money in places a generalist may not look: margin by channel and product, cash tied up in stock, and the terms retailers and distributors set. The right adviser talks about those from the first call.

The search often starts with a trigger: a raise, an exit, or a board asking for better reporting. That trigger should shape the shortlist. If you are raising in the next year, raise experience matters more than if you simply need a cash forecast. If you are still deciding whether you need a CFO at all, start with our UK D2C founder's guide to hiring a fractional CFO, which covers when to hire and what good scope looks like.

The checklist: eight criteria

Compare every adviser on your shortlist against these eight points.

1. Consumer brand experience. Have they worked inside or alongside D2C, Shopify, Amazon or FMCG brands? What good looks like: specific brands or anonymised examples, and the finance problems they solved there, not a general claim to "work with ecommerce".

2. Channel and wholesale margin knowledge. Can they calculate contribution margin by channel and SKU? Contribution margin is what each sale leaves after product cost, delivery, packaging, payment fees and the marketing spent to win it. What good looks like: they ask how you split direct, marketplace and wholesale sales, and they know wholesale margin depends on the retailer's cut, promotions and listing fees.

3. Stock and working capital. Working capital is the cash tied up in running the business day to day, mostly stock and money owed by retailers. What good looks like: they build stock orders, supplier terms and retailer payment terms into the cash forecast, so you see the stock cash pinch before it arrives.

4. Board reporting. Can they show you a board pack they have built? What good looks like: one page that answers what the business earned, where cash is going and how last month compared to the forecast, with the detail behind it.

5. Raise and exit experience. If a raise or sale is coming, have they prepared a business for one? What good looks like: they have built a financial model and a data room (the folder of documents investors or buyers review), and they know what a quality of earnings review is: a buyer's check of how much of your profit is real and repeatable.

6. Fixed or hourly fees. How do they charge? What good looks like: a clear fee and scope in writing before you start, with raise or exit work quoted separately.

7. Who actually does the work. Is the person on the intro call the person doing the monthly work? What good looks like: a named person, and a clear answer about anyone else involved.

8. References. Can you speak to a founder they have worked with? What good looks like: a consumer brand founder at a similar stage, or anonymised examples where client names are confidential.

Fixed fee or hourly: how CFO advisors charge

CFO advisers charge in one of two ways: a fixed fee for an agreed scope, or time-based billing by the hour or the day. A fixed fee tells you the cost before the month starts. Hourly billing can suit a one-off question, but it makes an ongoing role hard to budget for and can make founders reluctant to pick up the phone.

Whichever model an adviser uses, ask for the scope in writing: what you get each month, what counts as extra, and how a raise or exit preparation is charged. Comparing what is delivered for the fee tells you more than comparing headline rates. For a wider look at how larger firms and specialists differ on fees and delivery, see accounting firm vs specialist fractional CFO.

Who will actually do the work?

Ask directly who will build your monthly pack, run the forecast and sit in your board meetings. In a larger firm or network, the person on the pitch may not be the person doing the work, which can work well as long as you know who it is and have met them. With an independent adviser, it is usually the same person throughout.

Location matters less than founders expect. Most of the work, from the monthly accounts to the forecast, is done remotely. What matters is whether the adviser will be on site for the moments that count, such as board meetings and key workshops, so ask how often that will be.

Questions to ask on the intro call

  1. Which consumer brands have you worked with, and what did you change in their numbers?
  2. How would you calculate our contribution margin by channel and SKU?
  3. How would you build stock orders and retailer payment terms into our cash forecast?
  4. Can I see a sample board pack?
  5. What does the first month produce, concretely?
  6. Have you prepared a business for a raise or a sale? What was in the data room?
  7. Do you work on a fixed fee, and what exactly does it cover?
  8. Who will do the work each month, and who sits in our board meetings?
  9. How often can you be on site?
  10. Can I speak to a founder you have worked with?

How Oro fits these criteria

Oro is a fractional CFO practice run personally by William Smithwhite, working with consumer brands from early growth up to around £40m. William co-founded Fjor, a D2C skincare brand, and ran it as CFO and COO: CAC came down by 90%, supplier renegotiation took gross margin on its best sellers to 80%, and he built the KPI dashboards, budget tracking and board reporting. Read the Fjor case study. Before that he was a Credit Suisse investment banker, on over $20bn of M&A, equity and debt transactions.

Monthly work is a fixed monthly fee, agreed upfront after an intro call, and raises or exit preparation are quoted as a fixed project fee. William does the work himself. We work with London and UK-wide brands, mostly remotely, with on-site visits in London around once a quarter for board meetings and key workshops. See about William, the case studies, and how we work with consumer brands and food and drink brands.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between a CFO advisor and a fractional CFO?
A CFO advisor can mean anyone who advises on finance, from a one-off project to an ongoing role. A fractional CFO is a specific arrangement: a CFO who works part-time inside your business every month, owning the forecast, the board pack and the investor reporting. Many founders searching for one are really looking for the other, so ask what the arrangement actually is.
Should a CFO advisor be London-based?
Not necessarily. Most of the work, from the monthly accounts to the forecast, is done remotely. What matters is whether they will be in the room for the moments that count, such as board meetings and key workshops, so ask how often they can be on site.
Do CFO advisors work on a fixed fee?
Some do, and some charge by the hour or the day. A fixed fee agreed upfront means you know the cost before the month starts and can call with a question without watching the clock. Ask for the fee and the scope in writing, and ask how raise or exit work is charged.
What should a CFO advisor cost?
It depends on the scope: monthly accounts on their own cost less than a full CFO role with board and investor reporting. Rather than comparing headline rates, compare what each adviser will deliver each month for the fee. Ask for a fixed fee in writing, covering exactly that scope.
How do I check references?
Ask to speak to a founder of a consumer brand they have worked with, ideally one at a similar stage to yours. Ask what the adviser delivered in the first few months, whether the numbers changed decisions, and who did the work. Where client names are confidential, ask for anonymised examples of the work instead.